In Search of Better Stories

Blame the Whores, Love the Pirates

Judgment from the hand of God is the conclusion given by nearly everyone around the world in the late 1600s for the mighty cataclysm that destroyed the Jamaican city of Port Royal. This British new world colony was as wicked as they come. However, for all the thousands of sermons and articles spawned by the level 12 earthquake and resulting Tsunami, not a single one connected God’s fierce anger with the brutality and wickedness of the slave trade. NOT ONE. Instead, the late 17th century’s long-winded preachers proclaimed that God’s ire was foisted upon the doomed city because of its sexual excess and drunkenness.

In the hierarchy of wickedness, what’s worse?

  • Losing your inhibitions based on too much rum punch followed by unbridled sexual passion under the hot Caribbean sun?
  • Buying and selling kidnapped people so that you can work them to death on your sugar plantation. Financial success through torture, intimidation and brutality?

From our vantage point, it seems like a no-brainer. If you were going to uncork a “God’s wrath” sermon on your congregation, option number 2 is the obvious choice. How come they missed this? It took 140 more years before the church woke up and finally put a stop to the trade. The church was wilfully blind to slavery because they benefited as much as anyone from it. Besides, it’s easier to pick on a whore or a drunk than the mayor or business leader of your town.

Shanked that one, didn’t we?

It seems to me that when wealth and power are at stake, it becomes exponentially more challenging to stay on the right moral path. Jesus was probably on to something when he said going through the eye of a needle is an easier task than having a rich man enter into heaven.

I picked up another bizarre observation from this book.

How come we love pirates so much? Themed birthday parties, professional sports teams, and Jack Sparrow all tell us that we have a warm place in our hearts for this historical figure. Opposite to this, no one likes a terrorist. Westerners, especially since 9/11, have only disdain for those kinds of people. What’s crazy is that the pirate is the original terrorist! Henry Morgan and his band privateers made a living out of murder, brutality, intimidation, extortion, blackmail, and theft. — Yah! let’s throw a birthday party in their honour for my eight-year-old!

How come so much love for cut-throats?

  • Is it because they were the first to practice democracy?
  • Is it because they were the original freedom-loving capitalists? Most of us in the West are big fans of democracy, freedom, and capitalism.
  • Is it because Henry Morgan was so wildly successful against the mighty Spanish empire? Everyone loves David and Goliath stories.
  • Is it because I am not Spanish? I suspect historians from the Iberian peninsula are not brimming with quite as much affection for those that sailed under the jolly roger.

It’s probably all of those reasons, but I know them for the murderous lot they were. In the end, the English empire that spawned them and empowered them killed them off. Once they served the Crown’s purpose for them, they were thrown out like the trash they were. Perhaps they get a bit of a sympathy vote for that.

Subscribe to my blog

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 187 other subscribers

Leave a Reply

Other Posts That Might Interest You

Destination Antigua

This tropical paradise boasts 365 beaches, one for every day of the year. In 30 days we went to as many of them as we


In 2013, we needed a break, so we all piled into the mini-van, drove to Cannon Beach Oregon, and shot a music video. This video